Comparing the Top Defibrillator Models for Home and Workplace Use
Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) are becoming more common in both homes and workplaces across the UK. This shift reflects growing awareness of the importance of rapid response in cases of sudden cardiac arrest (SCA). According to the Resuscitation Council UK, using a defibrillator within 3–5 minutes of collapse can increase survival rates to over 50%.
Choosing the right AED can vary significantly depending on where and by whom it will be used. For example, a model intended for a busy office may prioritise user prompts and self-checking features, while a home AED might focus on compact design and simplicity. This article compares five widely used defibrillator models designed for layperson use. All are fully automatic, meaning the device delivers a shock without requiring the user to press a button—ideal for high-stress situations.
Did You Know?
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) does not legally require defibrillators in UK workplaces, but employers are encouraged to include them in first aid needs assessments https://www.hse.gov.uk/firstaid/faqs.htm.
Observation:
In many offices and schools, defibrillator cabinets are visible but signage is often inconsistent, which may delay retrieval during an emergency.
Contents
Key Considerations
When selecting an automated external defibrillator (AED) for either home or workplace use, several factors should guide the decision. Each model comes with different features that may suit specific environments or user needs. Below are the primary considerations.
Ease of Use
All devices reviewed in this article are fully automatic. This means once the pads are attached, the device assesses the heart rhythm and delivers a shock automatically if required. Models with clear visual and audio instructions—such as the iPAD SP1 and ZOLL AED Plus—are especially helpful for untrained users.
Visual Prompts and Display
Some models, like the Mindray BeneHeart C2, include a high-contrast screen that displays step-by-step instructions. Others rely solely on voice prompts or LED indicators. A visual display can improve usability in noisy settings or for users with hearing impairments.
Maintenance and Readiness Checks
Most AEDs perform regular self-tests to ensure they are operational. Devices with visible status indicators (e.g. green check marks) make it easier to confirm readiness at a glance. Some models, such as the Heartsine Samaritan PAD 360P, feature integrated battery and electrode cartridges, simplifying replacement logistics.
Size and Portability
Portability may be essential for home users or settings with limited storage. Devices like the Heartsine 360P are lightweight and compact, whereas others with screens or added features may be bulkier.
Durability (IP Rating)
The Ingress Protection (IP) rating indicates resistance to dust and water. A higher IP rating (e.g. IP56 on the Heartsine 360P) suggests better protection in environments such as industrial sites or outdoor public access points.
Battery and Electrode Lifespan
Battery and electrode shelf life affects ongoing costs and maintenance frequency. Some models require separate replacements, while others use combined units (e.g. HeartSine PAD-PAK) with fixed lifespans, often 3–4 years.
Compliance and UK Distribution
Ensure the AED is CE-marked and available from authorised UK distributors. Devices should meet MHRA standards and be suitable for UK power supplies and usage environments.
ZOLL AED Plus Fully-Automatic Defibrillator
The ZOLL AED Plus is designed to support untrained users during cardiac emergencies with a strong focus on real-time CPR coaching. It uses ZOLL’s proprietary Real CPR Help® technology to provide visual and audio feedback on the rate and depth of chest compressions.
Key Features
CPR Feedback Sensor: Assesses and guides compression quality
Text Display and Voice Prompts: Reinforces actions in noisy environments
Long-lasting Battery: Uses 10 lithium Duracell 123a batteries with up to 5 years of standby life
High IP Rating: IP55, offering resistance to dust and water
Self-Testing: Performs daily, weekly, and monthly readiness checks
Fully Automatic Shock Delivery: No shock button required
Suitability
The ZOLL AED Plus is well-suited to workplaces where multiple staff members may need to operate the unit, including offices, warehouses, and schools. The robust CPR feedback can help maintain effective compressions even under stress.
Did You Know?
ZOLL’s Real CPR Help system uses an accelerometer built into the pads to measure chest movement and prompt improvements if compressions are too shallow or too slow.
Observation:
Some users have noted the larger size of the ZOLL unit makes it less suitable for compact wall cabinets or mobile first aid kits.
Mindray BeneHeart C2 (Fully Automatic with Screen)
The Mindray BeneHeart C2 is a fully automatic AED designed with a colour touchscreen interface and adaptive guidance. It is intended for public-access and workplace environments where visual prompts can enhance usability.
Key Features
Colour TFT Screen: Displays step-by-step instructions and illustrations
ResQNavi™ Technology: Adjusts guidance based on user behaviour and pace
CPR Guidance: Visual and voice prompts help ensure correct compression technique
IP55 Rating: Protects against dust and low-pressure water jets
Pad Compatibility: Uses standard adult/paediatric pads with clear expiration indicators
Battery Life: Up to 5 years standby; device performs daily and weekly self-checks
Suitability
The BeneHeart C2 is especially suitable for indoor public locations, larger offices, or healthcare-adjacent settings where untrained responders may benefit from more visual instruction. The screen supports multiple languages if configured.
Did You Know?
ResQNavi™ can detect the user's response speed and modify the pace of instructions, making it one of the few AEDs with semi-adaptive coaching.
Observation:
The touchscreen may be less visible in direct sunlight or bright outdoor conditions, making it better suited to indoor use.
Mindray BeneHeart C1A Fully-Automatic Defibrillator
The Mindray BeneHeart C1A is a fully automatic AED focused on speed, simplicity, and reliability. It features voice prompts and LED indicators but omits the screen found in the C2 model. This makes it a lighter and more compact option, while still retaining critical support features.
Key Features
ResQNavi™ Guidance: Adjusts voice prompts based on the responder’s actions
CPR Assistance: Includes metronome and audio feedback
ClearPad™ Technology: Confirms pad placement to reduce delays
IP55 Rating: Suitable for most indoor and light outdoor conditions
Quick Shock Analysis: Capable of rhythm assessment in under 5 seconds
Combined Adult/Paediatric Pads: Switchable with a simple toggle
Suitability
The C1A is ideal for organisations or communities that require a dependable, easy-to-use AED without advanced visual interfaces. It is frequently used in schools, retail premises, and housing associations.
Did You Know?
The C1A can deliver a shock in as little as 7 seconds from pad placement—faster than many competitor models.
Observation:
Its simplified interface reduces the likelihood of confusion, particularly for infrequent users, but may be less instructive in noisy environments where voice prompts could be harder to follow.
iPAD SP1 Fully-Automatic Defibrillator
The iPAD SP1 is a fully automatic AED widely adopted across public-access and community locations in the UK. It combines simplicity with intelligent features such as automatic paediatric mode and dual-language support.
Key Features
Clear Voice Prompts: Guides users through every step
Visual Indicators: LED icons show pad placement, battery status, and operational readiness
Automatic Shock Delivery: Delivers shock without requiring manual input
Child/Adult Mode Switch: Allows one set of pads to be used for both age groups
Dual Language Button: English and a second preset language (e.g. Welsh, Polish)
IP55 Rating: Water and dust resistant
Self-Diagnostics: Runs daily and monthly checks
Suitability
The SP1 is well-suited to schools, leisure centres, and public buildings. Its dual-language feature also makes it appropriate for multicultural workplaces or councils.
Did You Know?
The iPAD SP1 is one of the NHS Supply Chain’s recommended models and is listed on the Department of Health and Social Care's national defibrillator framework.
Observation:
In some community cabinets, the iPAD SP1’s language button can confuse users who press it unintentionally during emergencies. Labelling this clearly helps avoid delays.
Heartsine Samaritan PAD 360P Fully-Automatic AED
The Heartsine Samaritan PAD 360P is a compact, lightweight defibrillator designed for ease of use in home and public-access settings. It features a fully automatic shock function and a combined battery and electrode cartridge system for simplified maintenance.
Key Features
Fully Automatic Shock Delivery: No shock button required
Integrated PAD-PAK™ Cartridge: Battery and electrodes in one unit, with a 4-year shelf life
Clear Visual and Audio Prompts: LED indicators and voice instructions for each step
CPR Coaching: Audio metronome guides chest compression rate
IP56 Rating: One of the highest dust and water resistance ratings in the AED market
Lightweight Design: Just 1.1 kg, highly portable
Suitability
The 360P is ideal for home users, sports clubs, community halls, and rural environments. Its compact design and long shelf life minimise ongoing effort and storage needs.
Did You Know?
The HeartSine PAD-PAK combines battery and electrodes into one unit, reducing confusion during replacement and ensuring both components are always in-date together.
Observation:
Some users note the absence of a visual screen makes it less suitable for noisy or visually impaired settings, though the simple interface improves user confidence in quiet environments.
Comparison Table
| Model | Shock Delivery | CPR Guidance | Screen Type | Dual Language Support | Child Mode | IP Rating | Weight | Battery/Electrode Shelf Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ZOLL AED Plus | Fully Automatic | Real-time audio & visual feedback | Text display only | No | Separate pads required | IP55 | Approx. 3.1 kg | 5 years (batteries); pads ~5 years |
| Mindray BeneHeart C2 | Fully Automatic | Audio & screen guidance (adaptive) | Colour touchscreen | Yes (if configured) | Toggle on same pads | IP55 | Approx. 2.3 kg | Battery 5 years; pads ~3 years |
| Mindray BeneHeart C1A | Fully Automatic | Audio prompts with metronome | None | Yes (if configured) | Toggle on same pads | IP55 | Approx. 2.0 kg | Battery 5 years; pads ~3 years |
| iPAD SP1 | Fully Automatic | Audio prompts with metronome | None | Yes (button controlled) | Switch on same pads | IP55 | Approx. 2.4 kg | Battery 4 years; pads ~2 years |
| Heartsine PAD 360P | Fully Automatic | Audio prompts with metronome | None | No | Separate pads or PAD-PAK | IP56 | Approx. 1.1 kg | 4 years (PAD-PAK combined) |
Choosing the Right AED for Your Environment
Each of the models reviewed offers advantages for specific settings. The best choice depends on who may need to use the AED, the location’s risk level, and available storage or maintenance support.
For Workplaces with Multiple Staff or Public Footfall
Recommended models:
ZOLL AED Plus – Strong CPR coaching for minimally trained responders
Mindray BeneHeart C2 – Touchscreen guidance is beneficial in busy, multilingual environments
iPAD SP1 – Dual-language support and paediatric switch are ideal for schools and councils
These settings benefit from devices with robust prompts, visible status indicators, and built-in child mode. The inclusion of CPR feedback helps maintain quality compressions while waiting for emergency services.
For Home or Small Business Use
Recommended models:
Heartsine PAD 360P – Compact, cost-effective, and simple to maintain with combined PAD-PAK
Mindray BeneHeart C1A – Offers advanced reliability in a simple interface without a screen
In domestic or low-footfall locations, ease of storage and minimal upkeep are important. Fully automatic models reduce decision-making for untrained users, while lighter weight supports portability.
For Community Access Cabinets
Recommended models:
iPAD SP1 – Widely used in UK community schemes; public familiarity can improve response
Heartsine PAD 360P – High IP rating makes it suitable for outdoor cabinets
Devices in public-access settings must be robust, intuitive, and have widely available replacement parts. Visibility and familiarity are also important—especially in emergencies involving passersby.
Did You Know?
All five models in this guide are suitable for use by untrained members of the public under UK guidance, as long as voice prompts are followed and the pads are placed correctly.
Observation:
Defibrillator choice often comes down to user confidence. Simpler designs may offer fewer features, but in high-stress situations, clarity often outweighs capability.
FAQs
-
No. All AEDs in this comparison are designed for use by laypersons without medical training. UK guidance supports public use of AEDs with voice or screen prompts to guide every step. However, basic CPR training can still improve confidence and outcomes.
-
The IP (Ingress Protection) rating indicates how resistant the device is to dust and water. For example, IP55 or IP56 means the AED can withstand low-pressure water jets and limited dust ingress, making it more durable in outdoor or workshop settings.
-
Yes. Models like the iPAD SP1, Mindray C1A, and C2 allow adult and child use through a toggle or switch. Others, such as the ZOLL AED Plus and Heartsine PAD 360P, require either child-specific pads or a paediatric PAD-PAK.
-
AEDs automatically analyse the heart rhythm and will not deliver a shock unless necessary. All models reviewed are designed to prevent inappropriate shocks.
-
Most AEDs run regular self-checks and display visual indicators (e.g. green tick or flashing light) if ready to use. Maintenance typically involves checking pad expiry dates and battery status every few months. Some models use combined cartridges (like the PAD-PAK) to simplify this.
Sources
Below is a list of live sources used to compile product details, usage guidance, and comparisons:
ZOLL Medical UK – AED Plus Product Page
https://www.zoll.com/uk/defibrillators/aed-plus
Used to confirm device features such as Real CPR Help, IP rating, and maintenance details.Mindray – BeneHeart C2 Product Page
https://www.mindray.com/en/product/BeneHeart_C2.html
Provided technical details on touchscreen guidance, ResQNavi™ system, and battery life.Mindray – BeneHeart C1A Product Page
https://www.mindray.com/en/product/BeneHeart_C1A.html
Source for physical specifications, CPR support features, and child mode configuration.iPAD – SP1 Defibrillator Overview
https://www.ipad-aed.com/product/ipad-sp1/
Used to confirm dual-language support, IP rating, and public access adoption in the UK.HeartSine – Samaritan PAD 360P Page
https://heartsine.com/product/heartsine-samaritan-pad-360p/
Confirmed PAD-PAK design, IP56 durability, and suitability for home or rural settings.Resuscitation Council UK – Early Defibrillation Guidelines
https://www.resus.org.uk/library/2021-resuscitation-guidelines/early-defibrillation
Provided clinical context for AED use timing and survival rate data.Health and Safety Executive (HSE) – First Aid FAQs
https://www.hse.gov.uk/firstaid/faqs.htm
Clarified that AEDs are not legally required but recommended in first aid assessments.
